MONGOLIAN "STAG STONES"
The cosmology of the pasforalists, hunters and warriors
of the steppes in the First Millennium BC
Dr. Jérôme MAGAIL


        Since 2000, the French Archaeological Mission in Mongolia, has been studying the Xiongnu necropolis of Gol Моd 450 kilometres west of the capital Oulan-Bator (Fig. 1). From the 2nd Century BC, the Xiongnu harassed the Han Chinese Empire, causing it to undertake the first constructions of the Great Wall.

There are relatively few traces of these illiterate nomads, hunters and warriors whose territory was bigger than the area of present-day Mongolia. In order to better understand the origin of their habits, customs and cosmology, а part of the research carried out by the French Mission relates to remains from before this period. The tribes, confederated in the second half of the First Millennium BC to constitute а vast nomad empire, have left behind superb rock art compositions. These are the funerary steles known as "Stag Stone" (Fig. 2). At Gol Моd, in а cemetery dating before the Xiongnu necropolis there are still five steles of this type to be seen.


Fig. 1. Map of Mongolia and surrounding areas.


Fig. 2 : Stéle 1 at Gol Mod.

         These monoliths, some as high as 3 m, have various iconic themes whose style is identical to that from Eastern Mongolia to the Altai, from the Gobi to the Transbaikal. From the end of the 2nd Millennium to the 3rd Century BC, the artists systematically spread out the figures in the same way from the bottom to the top of each stele. The Gol Моd Stele 1 (Fig. 3) illustrates this spread perfectly:
- at the top, two different-sized circles are inscribed showing the sun and the moon;
- under the stars, in the middle part, stags with long rounded antlers are rushing towards the top or the bottom of the stele;
- at the base, there are different weapons, shown schematically (shields, daggers, axes and bows). Thus, the engraved grouping is а cosmology where each theme corresponds to an area of the Universe: the stars for the sky, the stags occupy an intermediate terrain and the weapons represent the terrestrial space occupied by Man.


Fig.3 : Stèle 1 at Gol Mod.

А fourth sector, the part of the monolith buried in the earth, certainly relates to the subterranean world, the world of the dead person. On Gol Моd Stele 1, а geometric motif, engraved at the foot of the monument, evokes the separation between the terrestrial and underworld realms. The iconographic themes are often separated by а geometric motif to clearly mark the different areas of the Universe: on Gol Моd Stele 4, а stag is crossing one of these fringes separating the lower part from that of the arms, represented by а shield (Fig. 4). 

The presence of small cervids, at the base of the monument, underlines their psychic role; herds of deer plunging into the world of the dead and surging up from the sepulchral space to rejoin the celestial regions. Their bodies have been deliberately elongated to make clear their movements between the two cosmological extremes. Their silhouette, marked by the rounded form of their antlers and their legs folded under the stomach, is also found in the mobiliary art of the Steppe. Moulded, sculpted and engraved cervids, from the Caucasus to Eastern Mongolia, show very close stylistic particularities. Numerous metal deer (Fig. 5) deposited in Southern Siberian graves close to Minusinsk have similar forms (see map). The cosmology of the art of the "Stag Stones" existed in several iconographic and ritual forms in the Steppe populations of the First millennium BC. Certain horned animals seem to have played a mediating role, enabling the spirits of the dead to pass into the supernatural world beyond our own. In Eastern Kazakhstan (Altai), the team from the Central Asian French Archaeological Mission discovered that this passage to the next world could be shown by other stratagems. In the 3rd Century BC a Saka prince was buried with 13 horses with false horns fixed to their foreheads. In this princely kourgan at the site of Berel' (see map), the sacrificed horses were fitted with pairs of wooden horns imitating those of ibex. This idea was adopted in several places, particularly at Pazyryk whose remains in gold coated wood are preserved at the Hermitage of St Petersburg. The horse seemed to have become the domesticated "ferryman" that had to be made-up fo be reintegrated into the original bestiary. The important place of the stag in Steppe religious representations is linked to its status as a wild animal animated by natural spirits. Its annual movements, the loss and growth of the antlers with the seasons related back to cosmic movements. Its hunting was not just a predatory activity but also an opportunity to distinguish the best warriors and to incorporate the tracking of the animal into a sacrificial rite. This type of practice very likely lasted through from prehistory to antiquity. Numerous hunting scenes were engraved, particularly in the Bronze Age in Western Mongolia, where can still be seen archers aiming at animals sometimes surrounded by dogs. Ancient Chinese texts (Shiji, 110: 2888) state that the Xiongnu used collective hunts to train for war.


Fig. 4 : Stèle 4 at Gol Mod.

What seems to be a hunting scene was discovered on a rock 6 km west of Gol Mod. Three cervids seem to be being chased by a horseman (Fig. 6). In a style very different from the "Stag Stones"; the stag, the deer and the faun and their pursuer are very badly effaced. These engravings, seemingly from the Earl y Bronze Age, will be studied in more detail during Summer 2004.


Fig. 5. Applique in the form of a stag. Siberian Bronze, Minusinsk region, Vth Cenfury BC. 6,8 cm long. Musée Guimet, Paris.


Fig. 6. Stone engraved with cervids.
6 km from Gol Mod.

The "Stag Stones" also enable an understanding of the significance of the animals represented on the belt buckles and weapons of Central Asian nomads (Fig. 7). This bestiary that was worn, sometimes even tattooed (Pazyryk), certainly had a propitiatory role helping men to be better warriors. The force and spirit of the animal were captured and diffused by the object showing it. The animal fights frequently moulded on swords and belt buckles demonstrated the vigour necessary in inter-tribal combats. Under the funerary "Stag Stones" decorated with daggers, axes and shields rested a warrior buried with his own arms (Fig. 8). At Gol Mod, a dagger and a bow were engraved on the side of one of the steles (Fig. 9). The arms are always shown in a very schematic way compared with the stags.

Linked to warfare, weapons were also part of the attributes of heads of families and clans who wore them both for display and prestige.


Fig. 7. Detail of engraving of weapons an Gol Mod Stele 1.


Fig. 8. Short sword, Northern China, Vth Century BC. Length = 26 cm. Musée Guimet, Paris.


Fig. 9. Stèle 2 at Gol Mod, engraved with a short sword and a bow.

Certain of them perhaps had the rote of canalising supernatural powers likely to intercede in the favour of their possessors. The Tagar civilization produced superb halbards, the base of whose blades had an animal statuette carved from the block. Such arms, whose fragility precluded their use in battle, were probably carried in rituals and ceremonies.

Among the Xiongnu, the vaunting of the warrior life reached its apogee. At the summit of their social hierarchy, power was not transmitted in a hereditary fashion as with the Han Chinese: The Steppe Emperor (the chanyu) was elected among the best warriors. This conferred on him the title of "Son of Heaven and Earth" and he became the incarnation of the Sun and the Moon before whom he prostrated himself each morning and evening (Shiji, 110: 2892-2899).

 
Fig.10. Sun and moon, iron, Xiongnu objects from Egiin Gol.
Oulan-Bator Academy of Sciences.


Fig. 11. Stèle 5 at Gol Mod, white granite,
broken and lying on the ground.

A metal sun and moon (Fig. 10) have been found by the French Archaeological Mission in Mongolia in a Xiongnu tomb at Egiin Gol (see map). These iron pieces decorated the coffin and enabled the dead man's spirit to pass to the next world. Several centuries before, the "Stag Stones"; whose summits were engraved with two circles, already showed the relationship between the warrior and the stars (Fig. 11). The passing of the spirit was tightly bound to the position of the monolith and to its iconography. If the body of the nomad was now sedentary, the funerary art had to perpetuate the journey of his soul.

Conclusion
Before the great Scythian and Xiongnu empires, the "Stag Stones" represented a very codified art that required a sophisticated technical and artistic apprenticeship. The style, the iconographic themes and their distribution show such similarity from one stele to another that the artists must have strictly observed the same rules, leaving little place to personal creativity. In the pluriethnic context of the First millennium, these rock groupings suggest an astonishing cultural coherence over such a vast territory.

The cervids with their elongated muzzle and large antlers were undoubtedly the codification of the final ascension towards the supernatural world. They were the mount of the soul obliged to leave the Steppe, similar to the auxiliary spirits which helped the shaman make his journeys. The same leaping animals were represented on the Scythian shields and belts. The adoption of this iconography over such great distances is certainly linked to the powers that the nomad cultures attributed to these images during funerary and shamanic rituals. Finally, the Mongolian "Stag Stones" have the characteristic of steppe art which has its significance only in movement. It is necessary to walk around Steles 1 and 4 of Gol Mod to grasp the coming and going of the cervids between Heaven and the Steppe. On one face they are shown descending to Earth, while on the other they are bounding towards the sun and the moon. At 70 km from Gol Mod, the same model can still be understood on a very worn stele, decorated with six animals. Three stags, engraved on one part and another of the monument, are in opposed movement (Fig. 12-13). It is now impossible to know who were the trio mounting towards Heaven, but as with ail the Mongolian "Stag Stones"; it is part of an exceptional heritage whose protection and study contributes to the knowledge of the history of the Steppe.



Fig. 12 & 13. North and South sides of a broken stele, 70 km west of Gol Mod.

BIBLIOGRAPHIE SOMMAIRE
 

Bazarbaeva G.A., Francfort H.-P., Samashev Z.S., Zhumabekova G.S., 2000. – "Le kourgane de Berel’ dans l’Altaï kazakhstanais", Arts Asiatiques, N°55, Paris, pp.5-20.

BEFFA M.-L. & DELABY L. 1999. – "Festins d’âmes et robes d’esprits - Les objets chamaniques sibériens du Musée de l’Homme", Mémoires du Muséum national d’Histoire naturelle, Publications Scientifiques du Muséum, Paris, Tome 181.

DELACOUR C., 2001. – De bronze, d’or et d’argent - Arts somptuaires de la Chine, Réunion des musées nationaux, Paris.

DEVLET A. Marianne, 1996. – "Murgur-Sargol, sanctuaire de l’âge du Bronze sur l’Iénisséi", Tombes gelées de Sibérie, Dossiers d’archéologie, Editions Faton, N°212.pp.58-63.

FRANCFORT H.-P., 1996. – "Art rupestre et tombes gelées", Tombes gelées de Sibérie, Dossiers d’archéologie, Editions Faton, N°212.pp.2-9.

JACOBSON E., 1993. – The Deer Goddess of Ancient Siberia: A Study in the Ecology of Belief, Brill Academic Publishers.

JACOBSON E., KUBAREV V., TSEVEENDORJ D., 2001. – "Répertoire des pétroglyphes d’Asie Centrale, Mongolie du Nord-Ouest Tsagaan Salaa/Baga Oigor", Mémoires de la Mission archéologique française en Asie Centrale, De Boccard, Paris, 2 vol., fascicule N°6.

HAMAYON R., 1998. – "L’épingle du jeu", Plus réel que le réel, le symbolisme, Revue du M.A.U.S.S., La Découverte/M.A.U.S.S., N°12, 2e semestre. pp.103-121.

HAMAYON R., 1990. – La chasse à l’âme. Esquisse d’une théorie du chamanisme sibérien, Société d’ethnologie, Nanterre.

KUBAREV V. D, 1996. – "L’art antique des montagnes d’or", Tombes gelées de Sibérie, Dossiers d’archéologie, Editions Faton, N°212.pp.42-57.

KUBAREV V. D., 1979. – Drevnie Izvayaniya  Altaya. Olennie kamni, Novossibirsk.

MAGAIL J., 2003. – "Entre steppe et ciel", Mongolie, le premier empire des steppes, Actes Sud & Mission archéologique française en Mongolie, Arles, pp.182-208.

MINIAEV S., 2002. – "Les Huns en Sibérie : découvertes et problèmes", Les Dossiers d’Archéologie, ed. Faton, N°270, pp.62-69.

NOVGORODOVA E. A., 1989. –  Древняя Монголия, Hаука, Москва.

RUDENKO S. I., 1970. – Frozen tombs of Siberia – The Pazyryk Burials of Iron-Age Horsemen, J.M. Dent & Sons Ltd, London.

RUDENKO S. I., 1962. – Kultura Khunnov i noinulinskie kurgany, Isdatelstvo Akademii Nauk SSSR, Moskva /Leningrad.

SAVINOV D. G., 1994. - Olennie kamni v kulture kotchevnikov Evrasii (Les pierres à cerf dans la culture des nomades d’Eurasie), SPb : Izdatelstvo S.-Peterburgskogo universiteta.

SCHILTZ V., 1985. – "Les Scythes et le monde des steppes", Le grand atlas de l’archéologie, Encyclopædia Universalis, Paris, pp.210-225.

SHER Y. A., 1980. – Ranniy etap skifo-sibirskogo zverinogo stilya, Skifo-sibirskoe kulturno-istoritcheskoe edinstvo, Kemerovo.

Shiji, Zhonghua shuju, Pékin, 1998.

TCHLENOVA N.L. 1962. – "Ob olennykh kamnyakh Mongolii i Sibiri", Mongolskij arkheologitcheskij sbornik, Academiya Nauk SSSR, pp.28-35.

TIVANENKO A. V., 1995. – "Olennie kamni Zabaïkaliya" (Les pierres à cerf de la Transbaïkalie), Kulturi i pamyatniki bronzovogo i rannego jeleznogo vekov Zabaïkaliya i Mongolii, BNTs SO RAN, Rossiyskaya Akademiya Nauk, Ulan-Udè, c. 102.

TSEVEENDORJ D., 1979. – "Mongol nutgaas oldson zarim bugan khöshöö", Arkheologiin suudlal, tome VII, fascicule 13, Ulaanbaatar.

TSEVEENDORJ D., 1999. – МОНГОЛЫН ЭРТНИЙ УРЛАГИЙН ТҮҮХ, Académie des sciences de Mongolie – Institut d’histoire, Ulaanbaatar.

TSEVEENDORJ D., 2002 – МОНГОЛЫН АРХEОЛОГИ, Ulaanbaatar.

TSEVEENDORJ D., 2003. – "Töv Aziin ertnii nüüdeltchdiin bambai", Archaeological study in Mongolia, collection of research articles and reports 1973-1982, Ulaanbaatar, T1.pp.48-52.

VOLKOV V. V., 1981. – Olennie kamni Mongolii, Nautchniy Mir, Ulaanbaatar.

 


  • Page d'acueil | Retour page Mongolie | Les thèmes iconographiques des "pierres à cerfs" | English version |

  • Contactez l'auteur - Dr. Jérôme MAGAIL - SITE EN EVOLUTION